After Ellis's initial claim request, he was given a pension number which follows his paperwork through the pension file. Every paper has that number, even the earliest papers when he had not yet been approved for a pension for his service in the Civil War.
Ellis was examined by two physicians who submitted affidavits on "Additional Evidence" forms. Dr. W. J. McDowell submitted an affidavit on December 11, 1890, which, in part, reads:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6e9ff/6e9ffdc99435ed08493487a6f9e5bfa3a771a268" alt=""
I have personally examined the applicant Ellis H. Biggerstaff of Co. D. 157 Regt, Ohio [illegible] [illegible] on this 10th day of December 1890–
I find him with history and present existence of Catarrhal trouble and chronic bronchial troubles. Symptoms. Headache, discharge from the nose, cough and almost constant throat iritation [sic], and reports constant tendency to take “cold” - Inability to withstand exposure. Has had trouble with his stomach and bowels, – gives history of lung trouble Unable to work any whatever for several months at a time. – There is some dullness on percussion over left lung . – Applicant states that he suffers constantly with his lung –––
I further declare that I have no interest in said case and am not concerned in its prosecution.
Wm. J. McDowell [signature]
Two weeks later, Dr. R. F. Gant examined Ellis and submitted another affidavit in which he stated:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e412b/e412bb6fdb777c3cf2cd77507d9f1dd2ed71f954" alt=""
I further declare that I have no interest in said case and am not concerned in its prosecution.
R. F. Gant, MD [signature]
In a Surgeon's Certificate, form 3--111, the examiner concurs with the findings of the other two physicians. The next document (by date) is "Invalid Pension."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7a663/7a66333a3c4adbfe8bcab78571487bbcacaeacd8" alt=""
Ellis was awarded a pension of $8.00 per month commencing on July 26, 1890. Ellis began the paperwork to obtain a pension on July 19, 1890, and after 8 1/2 months was finally approved.
The value of $8.00 in 1891 was approximately equivalent to the value of $192.00 in 2010.
(You can click on any image to view it larger. When you're finished looking, click the back arrow on your browser.)
Also about Ellis Bickerstaff's Pension File:
Ordering Civil War Compiled Military Service Records
Reviewing Civil War Compiled Military Service Records
Ordering a Civil War Pension File
His Civil War Pension File Arrived
Civil War Pension File: First View
Civil War Pension File: Inventory
Civil War Pension File: Chronological Overview of Papers Pertaining to Ellis
Claim for Disability Pension - Civil War Pension File
That's not a big pension at all! It's interesting that both of the doctors stated that they had no interest in the case and were not concerned in it's prosecution.
ReplyDeleteAnd I wonder what catarrhal trouble is...I'll have to look that up.
It is amazing the same attitudes were found one hundred fifty years ago. Things never change.
ReplyDeleteMy great grandfather got somewhere about the same amount. He also had to jump through hoops and was denied several times too.