Monday, October 20, 2025

Can I Trust the Informant's Information When Only His/Her Last Name Is Given? -- Thomas H. Nelson's Death Certificate

Thomas H. Nelson, son of Robert and Jane (Watson) Nelson.  I searched for this death certificate knowing, or at least hoping, that it would name his parents, thereby confirming some already-collected information. 

This is the death certificate.
This is the transcription.
State of Ohio
Bureau of Vital Statistics
Certificate of Death
PLACE OF DEATH   County of Jefferson   Registration District No. 2698   File No. 43634
Village of Mingo Jct    Registered No. 45.
  2   FULL NAME   Thomas H. Nelson
PERSONAL AND STATISTICAL PARTICULARS
  3   SEX   Male
  4   COLOR OR RACE   White
  5   Widowed
  6   DATE OF BIRTH   Jan 31, 1842
  7   AGE   76 yrs.   5 mos.   27 da.
  8   OCCUPATION   Retired
  9   BIRTHPLACE   Ohio
PARENTS [lines 10-13]
10   NAME OF FATHER   Robert W. Nelson
11   BIRTHPLACE OF FATHER   England
12   MAIDEN NAME OF MOTHER   Don’t Know
13   BIRTHPLACE OF MOTHER   England
14   THE ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE
        (Informant)              Nelson
        (Address)    Steubenville O
15   Filed   July 30 , 1918      G. E. Fithen
                                                     Deputy Registrar
MEDICAL CERTIFICATE OF DEATH
16   DATE OF DEATH   July 27, 1918
17   I HEREBY CERTIFY, That I attended deceased
from Dec. 20", 1917, to July 26, 1918
that I last saw him alive on July 26, 1918,
and that death occurred, on the date stated above, at 10 34 a m.
The CAUSE OF DEATH was as follows:
Chronic Interstitial Nephritis
(Signed) Edward J. G. Sanders , M. D.
July 29" , 1918            (Address)   Steubenville, O....
18   [blank]
19   PLACE OF BURIAL OR REMOVAL  Union      DATE OF BURIAL  July 30, 1918
20   UNDERTAKER   D. F. Coe   Steubenville O

Comments
I was surprised to see Thomas H.'s father's name as "Robert W. Nelson" on this record.  To date, every document I've found (there are at least eight of them) with Robert Nelson's name on it gives his name as "Robert Nelson" or "Robert Nelson Sr."  Other than on FamilySearch Family Tree (where another researcher chose to include the W.), this is the first time I find "my" Robert Nelson identified as "Robert W. Nelson," and the first record in which I see him with that middle initial.  Can it be accurate?  Should the number of documents I have indicate whether to include that middle initial?

The informant's last name is the only one given.  Who might it be?  Thomas H.'s son?  Robert's brother?  Or possibly a grandson of Thomas H.?  Can I trust the information from an unknown informant?  How well did he/she know the family?  Where did the information of Robert's name come from?  I understand that any informant can give the wrong information, including a close relative, one who doesn't really know the family, or one who assumes information.  And I realize that no informants were alive at the birth of their parents.  But I'm really hesitant to accept this informant's information, especially because it is the only time I've seen Robert Nelson with the middle initial of W.

I had so hoped this record would settle that problem of the "W" middle initial.  Not yet, I guess.  And does it really matter in the long run?

I did not expect to see Jane Watson's name on this record.  The moms and their maiden names usually seem to be forgotten, or not known.

How much weight do you put on information given by an informant, whether or not you know who it is?

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Sunday, October 19, 2025

Parents with No Known Names - SNGF on October 18, 2025

Randy Seaver's suggestion yesterday for this week's Saturday Night Genealogy Fun was this:
  1. Sometimes we don't know the full name of both of the parents of an ancestor.  In our family tree, those ancestors with no-known-name parents are the end-of-the-line, at least as far as we know. [Some researchers call them "brick walls."]
  2. Tell us about several of your ancestors that have no known-name parents, 
  3. When was the last time you looked for these not known parents? 

This is a topic I havn't thought about for a while, but one I'm happy to revisit.  For the grandparents below, it's not for lack of searching that I don't know their names.

Henry Carl Meinzen is my great-grandfather, my maternal grandfather's father.  Henry was born in Prussia/Hanover/Germany in 1837 and died in Ohio in 1925.   Family lore claims Henry's father's name as Carl.  However, Henry's sister Sophia Meinzen Kropp's death certificate gives their father's name as Deidrich.  I've been unable to locate a document that tells their town or city of birth and have found no church records that I can definitively associate with Henry, Sophia, or their father.

John Froman is one of my paternal great-great-grandfathers.  He was born about 1841 in Germany and died about December, 1871, in Mercer County, PA.  He arrived in the U.S. in 1856 at the age of 16 as Johannes Frommann along with Werner Frommann, 54 years; Maria, 21; Anna, 12; Elisabeth, 7; Heinrich, 5; Caspar, 4; and Christiane, 23.  I've not found evidence of Werner Frommann in any other documents (even with spelling variants).  Writing this reminds me that I might find a death record for one of John's siblings that gives parents' names, not that a death certificate will positively identify a parent, but it's another place to look.  

Christian Gerner and Mary E. Stahl are my second great-grandparents, my father's great-grandparents, born about 1820 and 1824, respectively.  They immigrated to the U.S. in 1852 with one child; other children followed in 1853.  I've found no information for either of their parents.  Both were born in Germany, as far as I can tell, and married in Germany, but I don't have a city or town name where they were born or married to help.

William Doyle is my third great-grandfather, born about 1802, probably in Northumberland, and died in 1838 in Northumberland, England.  I haven't yet been able to identify his parents.  With only a name, and a common one at that, and birth year, I'm still searching.

Robert Laws is another third great-grandfather.  He and William Doyle were in-laws: William's son and Robert's daughter married in 1863.  Robert died in 1881.  There were several men named Robert Laws in Northumberland, possibly relatives, but I haven't found a hint for Robert's parents' names yet.  (How I wish British church records included names of parents!)

Making this list reminds me that I need to search for the parents of these individuals again, possibly using the names of several/more of their children to help.  For some of them it's been at least 10 years.  A lot can happen with online records in 10 years!

Sometimes I think I have too many ancestors!

Thanks for the fun, Randy.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Sunday, October 5, 2025

Abel and Raymond: Two Who Disappeared - SNGF

For this week's Saturday Night Genealogy Fun Randy Seaver of Genea-Musings suggested we do this:
  1. Sometimes an ancestor or relative just disappears out of the records and we cannot find another record after a certain date. 
  2. Tell us about one or more of your relatives or ancestors who have disappeared and not been found since a certain date.  Do you have any idea of what might have happened to them?

Abel Armitage disappeared sometime after 1881.  He is one of my great-great-grandfathers, a coal miner who was born in Yorkshire West Riding, England, in 1821, and immigrated from Durham, England in 1864.  He settled in Steubenville, Ohio, where he continued the work of coal mining.  In the 1880 U.S. Census he is recorded as disabled.  The most recent evidence of him is in Steubenville City Council records in which he was awarded money from a court case against the city of Steubenville.  People don't just disappear!  Except he did.  I've searched every source I can think of that might be helpful including online court records, census records, newspapers of the time, probate records, cemetery records, and more.  One of his sons happens to share his father's name, so his name turns up often in records, but he's the wrong man.

I thought perhaps Abel might have moved to West Virginia, or Pennsylvania, but haven't found any records in either of those states.  My search of British records and newspapers was unsuccessful.  I thought he might have returned to England.  That was a challenge because there were two men named Able Armitage in the area where my Abel was born, one three years after my Abel.  I also searched a variety of name variations.  It seems strange that there's no obituary or death record.  Every now and then I search again, thinking new online records might shed some light.  

Raymond Doyle is the adopted son of my great-grandparents, William and Tressa Doyle, and my paternal grandfather Gust Doyle's brother.  He was born about 1904 or 1905, presumably in Mercer County, Pennsylvania..  By 1920 Raymond was living at the State Institution for the Feeble-minded in Polk, Pennsylvania, and the 1950 U.S. Census shows him living in the Mercer County Home in Coolspring Township, Mercer County, Pennsylvania.  I met Raymond sometime around 1960 at the County Home, but have no knowledge of what became of him after I met him.  My best guess is that he died at the County Home.

Since I don't know his birth name, I can't search for a birth record.  Adoption records are sealed in Pennsylvania so that's a closed door.  I thought there would be a record of his death in Pennsylvania death certificates, but have not found one.  The Mercer County home is no longer in existence and I haven't discovered if records are available somewhere, though it's likely they're sealed, too..  I have not found an obituary; I assume he would not have had one.  I haven't found him in any cemetery records.  And there seem to be no family records for Raymond. 

Again and again, these two men come to mind, almost as though they're pestering me.  I want to know what happened to them--it's as if knowing their end would allow me to put them, and the search for them, to rest.  

Thanks for the fun, Randy.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Sunday, September 14, 2025

Top Five Surprises in Genealogy Research - SNGF

Randy Seaver's suggestion for Saturday Night Genealogy Fun yesterday was this:
"What are your top five surprises you have found in your genealogy research and family history work?"
I was surprised to learn
  • that my father was a twin, that his twin sister died a few days after they was born, and that their mother died a few weeks later.  So sad for that little family.  (As I've mentioned before, I come from a long line of non-storytellers.)

  • that my maternal grandfather, W. C. Robert had so many siblings, which my mom and her siblings didn't seem to know.  It seems they knew only of Grampa, five sisters, and one brother.  In total there were 15 siblings, one of which I can't find.  Whenever anyone asked Grampa about his childhood and family he would say, "Go ask Aunt Mina."

  • that 3 of my great-grandmothers had 14 or more children:  Elizabeth Jane (Laws) Doyle had 14 children; Elizabeth (Armitage) Meinzen had 15 children; and Elvira (Bartley) Gerner had 16 children.  I'm in awe.

  • that my maternal grandmother's grandfather, Ellis Bickerstaff, committed suicide.  Such sorrow.

  • that two of my great-grandfathers, John Froman and William Doyle (the elder), died when their wives were pregnant.  Strong women.

  • how many of my ancestors among the first five generations (not including mine) were coal miners.   There are a total of ten.  On my father's side:  my father Lee Doyle, Gust Doyle, William Doyle, Andrew Doyle, William Doyle (the elder), Robert Laws, John Froman, and Jacob Saylor; and on my mother's side, Abel Armitage and Robert Nelson.  Strong men.

This was a great and fun activity, Randy.  Thank you.  It helped me realize how few family groups I've posted here.  I need to do that.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Saturday, September 13, 2025

A Reliable Informant for Mary A. Nelson's Death Certificate

I particularly love my ancestors who shared their family history, or at least their parents' names, with their children and spouses.  Since the early 1900s, Ohio death certificates ask for the first and last names of the deceased's parents and the mother's maiden name, as well as where they were born (though I have yet to learn a hometown from a death certificate).  Knowing parents' names makes finding the next previous generation so much easier.

My pursuit of Robert Nelson and his family led me to a record for one of his daughters, Mary A. Nelson.  Mary married William Watters in Steubenville, Ohio, in August, 1867.  Without the fact of their marriage I would be less certain this death certificate was for Robert and Jane Nelson's daughter.    

Below is Mary A. (Nelson) Watters's death certificate (viewable at FamilySearch with a free account) followed by an extraction of information from the document.
Extracted Information
Ohio Death Certificate for Mary A. Watters
White, female, widow
of 137 Wildon, Steubenville, Ohio
Died Oct 12, 1923, in Steubenville, Ohio, of cerebr[al] hemmorhage [sic]
Born February 4, 1849, in Steubenville, Ohio
Father:  Robt Nelson, born England
Mother:  Jane Watson, born England
Informant:  George Watters
Burial October 15, 1923, at Union Cemetery, Steubenville, Ohio 

A Thought
The informant, George Watters, is likely Mary's son who was born ~1884.  He appears in the 1910 census with his parents, Mary and William, and two other children.  I think it's important to know the identity of the informant.  A reliable informant who is a family member or close friend can provide the golden hint:  the deceased person's parents' names, including the mother's maiden name.  Without that name, it's hard to continue searching for ancestors.  If it happens that I know the informant's name but not the relationship, or don't recognize the name at all, I spend time trying to learn more about the person. 

Now I can more confidently search for a marriage record for Robert Nelson and Jane Watson.

And a Note
Concerning the word "reliable," it's often hard to know when an informant is reliable, and for me, reliability is on a continuum.  A person whose name I don't recognized and is not a family member I would consider unreliable until I researched the person.  I would consider a family member more reliable, but I would still research the individual to ascertain his or her relationship.  And, of course, even a "reliable" informant can give inaccurate information.  A daughter of one of my ancestors gave the information for her father and answered the questions as if for herself instead of her father's information.  The grief of death can rattle a person.  

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 
.

Thursday, August 28, 2025

Naturalization

While I was searching for Robert Nelson's immigration and naturalization documents, I came upon Kieran Healy's post, American, where he says, "I am writing this because I do not want to forget how I felt yesterday."  "Yesterday" was the day he became an American citizen after living in the U.S. nearly 20 years. 

I especially enjoyed and appreciated this post because he talks about part of the current naturalization process that I had never thought about much, the actual steps immigrants go through to become citizens -- the paperwork that must be completed to apply, the questions that are asked, the studying that must be done to learn the information to answer the questions correctly, the interview, the ceremony -- all briefly but with insight, in only a paragraph or two.

He mentions the tangle of immigration, politics, power, principle, authority, etc., that is part the current discussion among some in America.  He acknowledges them, yet focuses on his experience:  he writes about how he felt when he was in a room of other immigrants who were all there to take the Oath of Allegiance.    
I know the nationalities of my fellow oath-takers because of the next stage of the ceremony.  This was the Roll Call of Nations.  I did not know this was going to happen.  Every country of origin represented was announced in turn.  As your country was named, you were asked to stand up, and remain standing.  Afghanistan came first.  Then Algeria.  The last person to stand, immediately to my left, was from the United Kingdom.  There were twenty seven countries in all, out of only fifty or so people.  For me this part in particular was enormously, irresistibly moving.  It perfectly expressed the principle, the claim, the myth—as you please—that America is an idea.  That it does not matter where you are from.  That, in fact, America will in this moment explicitly and proudly acknowledge the sheer variety of places you are all from.  That built in to the heart of the United States is the republican ideal not just that anyone can become an American, but that this possibility is what makes the country what it is.  (Please go to Mr. Healy's post to read a continuation of his thoughts!)
Healy's post reminded me not to take citizenship in the United States for granted.  It also sent me to the USCIS Civics Test Textbook, "One Nation, One People," because I wondered if I could pass this qualifying test for U.S. citizenship.  What might I have forgotten from -- or never learned in -- my high school government class more than 50 years ago?  (There are five U.S. territories?!!!)  As an American citizen, I should know the answers without having to study beforehand and without having to answer from multiple choices, right?  They should have become a part of my core knowledge.  (Sadly, I don't think I could have passed the test without studying beforehand.)

These are some of the one hundred questions (in no particular order) asked on the citizenship test:
  1. When was the Declaration of Independence adopted? 
  2. What were the original 13 states? 
  3. What are the five U.S. territories? 
  4. When was the Constitution written? 
  5. Name one of the writers of the Federalist Papers. 
  6. When was the Declaration of Independence adopted? 
  7. What did the Declaration of Independence do? 
  8. What is an amendment? 
  9. What does the Constitution do? 
  10. During the Cold War, what was the main concern of the United States? 
  11. Who did the United States fight in World War II? 
  12. What do we show loyalty to when we say the Pledge of Allegiance? 
  13. Who makes federal laws?  
  14. What is the "rule of law?" 
  15. What are the Cabinet-level positions? 
  16. What are the powers of the federal government? 
  17. What powers belong to the states? 
  18. What promises do you make when you become a United States citizen?
Having learned a little about the current naturalization process, my mind turned to the process required of our 19th century ancestors to become citizens.  It seemed so much easier then:  live in the country a specific number of years, go to any "court of record," declare one's intention to become a citizen, return several years later, and become a citizen.  I think it was required to take a person to verify the immigrant's identify, yet there was no formal identification required. (When did formal identity become necessary?  After driver's licenses?)  The National Archives's article, "History of the Certificate of Citizenship, 1790-1956," tells me this was the "Old Law" period.  We don't get much helpful genealogy information (name, country of origin, and possibly when the individual came to America) from those records.  What we learn is when an ancestor became a citizen.

I've indexed plenty of naturalization records from the early to mid-1900s for FamilySearch.  Envy set in when I saw all the vital information ancestors had to declare to become citizens (birth date and year; birthplace; name of spouse including maiden name; birthplace of spouse; names of children and birthplaces; place of employment; profession; etc.) sometimes including photographs.  I was also surprised to see that some people were denied citizenship based on their moral (or immoral / less than upstanding) conduct.  I don't know if immigrants who became naturalized citizens during those years were required to take a test, or if it was about declaring allegiance and being morally upright.  

Some connection happened in my mind between Robert Nelson's and Kieran Healy's naturalization processes.  So very different steps in the processes and yet the same outcomes:  the solemn act of giving up citizenship in one's country of birth and adopting a different country as one's own.  As family historians I think for us it's more about the paper (or digital image) and what information we can find there, but as Healy suggests, it's truly more about what happens in the heart and mind.  I suspect that was so for our ancestors who moved to America and became citizens of the United States.  No doubt it was a momentous event for them, too. 

Thank you, Kieran Healy, for sharing your thoughts with us.  And congratulations on your citizenship and welcome to the United States of America.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

Monday, August 25, 2025

1830 Immigration Documents for Robert Nelson

I found two immigration documents for Robert Nelson and his family.  The first one was a passenger list, and the second was a National Archives index card.  The information is essentially the same but I like the passenger list because it more information about the ship, and names those who travelled with the Nelson family.

The first is the passenger list found at FamilySearch and made available by the National Archives.  You can view it here with a free FamilySearch account.  It is part of their  Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Passenger Lists, 1800-1882 collection.
The Transcription
C. S.    Printed for J. H. Barnes, Ship and Insurance Broker, opposite the Customs House, Philadelphia---by Russell & Mart???
C. 3.   
REPORT OR MANIFEST of all the Passengers taken on board the  Brig Panama  
whereof  Nathaniel Thomas  is Master, from  Newcastle   burthen
  253  Tons and owned by  George Loving, Nathaniel Thomas and John Binner 
of  Duxbury   and bound for  Philadelphia & Boston  

Name / Age / Sex / Occupation / To what Country belonging / Country of which it is their intention to become inhabitants.... [Robert and family are at the bottom of the page.]    
Robert Nelson, 30 years, male, Miner, from Great Britain and Ireland, to United States of America 
Jane Nelson, 23 years, female, [blank], from Great Britain and Ireland, to United States of America
James Nelson, 4 years, male, [blank], from Great Britain and Ireland, to United States of America 
Margaret Nelson, 2 years, female, [blank] from Great Britain and Ireland, to United States of America
George Bell, 44 [or 46] years, male, Miner, from Great Britain and Ireland, to United States of America
o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o - o

Below is the National Archives card which can be found here at FamilySearch (viewable with a free FamilySearch account).  It is in the FamilySearch Collection, United States. Emigration Records 1820-1874, Immigration Records 1820-1874.  It is image 3135 of 6024.
Transcription
    Family Name                            NELSON
    Given Name                              Robert
    Accompanied by                       Jane, James, Margaret
    Age:                                         30
    Sex                                           M
    Occupation                               Miner
    Nationality                               Gr. Br.
    Last Permanent Residence 
    (Town, Country, Etc.)                Gr. Br.
    Destination                               U.S.
    Port of entry                             Phila
    Name of vessel                         Panama
    Date                                         9-23-1830
    PC532

Notes and Comments
  • There is a discrepancy in Robert's son's name between census records and these immigration records.  Here his name is James; on census records it is Daniel.  Could one of those names have been a middle name and Robert and Jane were indecisive about what to call their son?  The estimated birth year is the same in census and immigration records.
  • The Nelsons travelled on the brig "Panama."  I searched for an image but didn't find one.  I didn't realize that a brig is a specific kind of ship, one with large, square-topped, billowy sails.  It must have been magnificent to be on deck under those grand sails.  (And probably not so grand below-deck.)
  • I was surprised that the passenger list had only one page of passengers, a total of 16.  The ship probably also carried cargo.  They would have had to make that long distance of travel worthwhile.
  • On the passenger list, Robert is listed with his wife Jane, and their two children James and Margaret.  It looks to me like George Bell is also listed with their family.  I had hoped a second page of passengers might shed some light on George's relationship to the family but without a second page, there's no help.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Sunday, August 24, 2025

The Layout of My Childhood Home for SNGF


Randy's Saturday Night Genealogy Fun challenge for August 23 was this:
Do you recall the layout of one of your family homes (a parent's home, a grandparent's home, your first home with your spouse/SO, etc.)?  Can you estimate the size of the house and the size of the rooms?  What features were in each room?  Can you draw the floor plan, showing doors, windows, etc.?
This sounded both fun and challenging.  I wrote about my childhood home years ago using photos but I had not considered the sizes of the room.  I'm in no way adept at estimating measurements that are longer than a foot so I could be completely wrong about how wide and deep the inside of our house was....  (I hoped the county auditor's website would have measurements but it didn't.)  I guess my drawing is somewhat proportional if inaccurate.

My parents owned the duplex and we lived in one side (except that the dividing wall on the second floor between the two sides of the house had been removed.  The house had a wide front which, when divided into the two sides, made the width and depth of each side about equal, though maybe a little deeper than wider.

This is my rough (very rough) drawing of the layout of the house.
The living room had originally been two rooms but sometime before I was born, my gather removed the dividing wall and it was one long room.  It sometimes seemed awkward because the seating was stretched from one end to almost the other, but it did feel spacious.

The kitchen had one wall with the refrigerator and sink and around the corner the stove.  Because the essentials weren't in a triangle against three walls, it allowed for a kitchen table to take up a good amount of floor space.  (Our current home as the sink, stove, and refrigerator on three walls.  No island or table for us in that part of the kitchen!)

The room beside the kitchen was somewhat of a work room.  My father's desk for repairing watches and jewelry was there, my mom's sewing machine was also there for a while, and eventually my mom's desk stood opposite my father's. 

The upstairs ran the width of the building but was narrower than the first floor.  It was one long hallway with four rooms opening off it.  The rooms on either end were larger than the rooms between them.  All had windows (two in the end rooms) and there were high windows along the back side of the hallway, but there was no air conditioning.  One fan in the hall did nothing to circular air in all four rooms, or in any of the rooms, if truth be told.  We sweltered on hot summer nights.

The wide front porch was one of my favorite places, especially in the summer.  It was a place to play games with friends, read, and watch the thunderstorms.  

As I think of this house now I think how compact it was, and my mom's motto was "a place for everything and everything in its place."  She was definitely the leader in running her household.

If I were to go back and visit, I'm sure it would seem much smaller than it did when I lived there.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Thursday, August 21, 2025

The Costs of Living in Earlier Times - Prices and Wages by Decade 1700s-2000s

I happened upon the website, University of Missouri Libraries' Prices and Wages by Decade, a few weeks ago when I was trying to learn whether Abel Armitage's settlement from a court case against the city of Steubenville would have been enough for him to return to England.  (It definitely would have.)  It didn't take me long to immerse myself (that is, go deeper down this Abel Armitage rabbit hole) in the dozens and dozens of options to learn about the financial concerns of ancestors who lived decades and centuries ago.  The website's unassuming header and description don't give much of a clue about what's hidden behind the gold tabs.
When I click on one of the yellow/gold century tabs below the title, I'm presented with clickable links for individual decades, for example, 1800-1809, 1810-1819, etc.  Sometimes information will be available at this website, but for the most part, it offers links to where a researcher can find further information.  This collection of links to further information is organized by categories, which include, etc.:
  • Wages in the United States
  • Wages by sex 
  • Wages by race
  • Wages by occupation
  • Wages by state
  • United Kingdom wages
  • Food prices
  • Clothing Prices
  • Health and Medicine prices
  • Communication rates  
  • Home, farm, and land prices
  • Travel and transportation prices
  • More prices in the United States include communication, household items, tools, guns & hunting, livestock, education, hotels, services
  • Cost of living and consumer expenditures in the U.S.
  • Foreign prices by country
  • United Kingdom prices
  • Quotable facts for the decade
  • Analysis, calculators, and exchange rates
  • Timeline -- Major economic events of the decade
  • And possibly others, depending on the decade 

The website states, 
This guide points to prices and wages found in primary sources for each decade back to the 1700s.  Our preference is government sources though we also use commercial catalogs, travel guides, newspapers, etc.  We point only to publications that are freely available online....

Since information is based on what can be gathered from various sources, there may not be information for your ancestor in a specific location in a specific decade.  Sometimes, information can be generalized across a wider geographic area and broader expense of time, but as a family historian you'd need to decide whether to do that or not. 

Other ways to learn prices, wages, and more financial information for our ancestors' time is to digitally search or page through newspaper for ads and articles, and to research individual items and locations.  I don't see this website as an only-place-to-look kind of resource.

This is the kind of website that is endlessly fascinating to me.  With so many ancestors living in so many different decades, with so much influencing and effecting their lives, and with both female and male ancestors, this website presents information in some form or another for all of them.  When I learn from a census that an ancestor's property was valued at $4,000.00 and that his personal estate was valued at $1500.00, I can't help but wonder teh cost of food or clothing or transportation or other necessities, or even luxuries, during that time.  I think information like this helps me understand the circumstance of the lives of my ancestors better.

The only negative I see is that there is no search bar, so I wasn't able to ask the cost of an item or service in a particular year in a specific location.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Friday, August 15, 2025

Why is Another Man's Name Crossed Off Robert Nelson's Naturalization Paper?

This 1844 naturalization record is for a man named Robert Nelson.  I believe the Robert Nelson of this record is my third-great-grandfather, but with so little personal information, it's hard to be certain.  I know that Robert lived in Jefferson County, Ohio, and that one of his children was born in Pennsylvania in about 1832.  Both support my belief that this is my grandfather's record.  (Click the image to open in a new tab so you can see it larger.) 

This is the transcription of the document.
TO THE HONORABLE THE  District Court  OF ALLEGHENY COUNTY, 
IN THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
The Petition of   John  S.  Patterson      Robert Nelson 
of               [blank]                  humbly sheweth:
That your petitioner is a native of  England 
and was heretofore a subject of  the Queen of Great Britain & Ireland 
and that he has resided within the limits and under the jurisdiction of the United States of 
America for five years, and within the State of Pennsylvania one year; and that two years 
prior to this application, that is to say, on the  18th  day of  May  in
the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and  forty  before the 
 Court of Common Pleas of Jefferson County Ohio 
your petitioner declared his intention of becoming a citizen of the United States, in the manner 
required by law, as in and by the certificate of  John  [T?] Patterson Clerk 
of said court, herewith exhibited,—that he will support the Constitution of the United 
States; and that he doth absolutely and entirely renounce, and forever abjure, all allegiance and
fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, and sovereignty whatever; and particularly to the 
 Queen of Great Britain & Ireland 
whereof he was heretofore a subject.  Your petitioner, therefore, prays that he may be admit-
ted to become a citizen of the United States of America. 
I,  Robert Nelson 
do swear, that the facts set forth in this, my petition, are true; and that I will support the Con- 
stitution of the United States; and that I do absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure forever, 
all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, and sovereignty whatever; and par-
ticularly, do absolutely and entirely renounce, and abjure forever, all allegiance and fidelity to 
 the Queen of Great Britain & Ireland 
whereof I was heretofore a subject. 
Sworn and subscribed in open Court, this  }                                 his 
 14 day of Sept 1844                                    }                        Robt.  x  Nelson 
     G R Ridale  [illegible letters]                                                    mark 
                                         Thomas Huscraft 
of  Allegheny County  and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, do 
swear, that the petitioner,  Robert Nelson 
has resided within the limits and under the jurisdiction of the United States of America five 
years, and within the State of Pennsylvania one year: to wit in 
                                                                                                   Allegheny County 
which place  is  within and under the Constitution of the United States; and that during his 
residence within the United States, he has behaved as a man of good moral character, attached 
to the Constitution of the United States, and well disposed to the good order and happiness of 
the same. 
Sworn and subscribed in open Court, this }         Thos Howcroft 
 9 day of Sept. 1844                                     }
                      Geo R Riddle  R 


Thoughts and Comments
What I really want to know about this record is why the clerk wrote in the wrong name then crossed it off  The crossed out name looks suspiciously like John S. (or T.) Patterson, the clerk's name.  Would it have been so hard for the county clerk to have given my grandfather a new, clean document instead of crossing out the name of another man and reusing the form?!  Was the county so poor they couldn't "waste" a page even due to mistakes or inaccuracy?  I'm not judging here, but had this been me, receiving a once-in-a-lifetime document, I might have insisted that I have my own paper with no one else's name on it.  A new document would have eliminated all questions and confusion.  Have you ever seen a document like this with a crossed-out name?

This is the first time I've seen a naturalization record in which the individual being naturalized had lived in two states by the time of his naturalization.  My other ancestors lived in the same state, and usually the same county, during the first years here in the U.S.  

In this document Robert Nelson renounces allegiance to the Queen of England, but nowhere in this record does it state, "Robert Nelson, you are now a citizen of the United States of America."  Am I missing other papers?  Or because Robert was in court to obtain naturalization, do we just assume he became a citizen?

I also notice that there are two dates on this record:  September 9, 1844, and September 14, 1844.  It seems that on the 9th, Robert Huscraft gave testimony for Robert, stating that he was a man of good moral character and during the time he's been in the U.S. he had honored the Constitution.  


This document is part of FamilySearch's collection, "Allegheny. Citizenship Records 1844–1846."   With a free FamilySearch account you can see it at  https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSM1-N7WN-1?view=fullText&keywords=Robt%20Nelson%2CRobert%20Nelson%2CUnited%20States%2CPennsylvania&lang=en&groupId%3F=&groupId= 

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Thursday, August 7, 2025

Down Another Dead-end Rabbit Hole, Searching for Abel Armitage

Some other blogger, probably Randy of Genea-Musings, posted that Chronicling America had added new newspapers.  I thought, Oh, maybe they'll have some Steubenville newspapers, or maybe there will be a reference to Abel Armitage this time when I check.  I periodically return to ancestors I'm still trying to find and search for their names.  This time I was so hopeful.

And, yes!  There was a reference to Abel Armitage in the Wheeling Sunday Register, November 15, 1900.  Well, I thought, it could be him.  He would have been nearly 80 that year.  Maybe it's an obituary.  So I clicked through.
The first thing I noticed was that there were only 22 pages in this newspaper.  The next thing I noticed was that there were no highlights, even as I scrolled through the links to the pages.  Not a single highlight.  What could this mean?  Surely Chronicling America wouldn't send me to a newspaper that didn't have a reference to the man whose name I typed in.

I began looking at the images page by page.  No highlights.   Well, I thought, after I finish looking for highlights on all the pages, I'll just have to search page by page.  When I arrived at page 11, I saw community names as headings.  One of them was Tiltonsburg, a small town near Steubenville.  I began to search for Abel's name.  And, YES!  There was "Abel Armitage."  Oh my heart, could it be my Abel?

You know how you see the name first, then stop reading because you're so excited?  After that moment of excitement I read the whole sentence:  "Mr. Abel Armitage is looking happy over the arrival of a boy."  No, my heart, it is not your Abel.

Definitely not my Abel, not at age 80 (with a wife not much younger) having a baby.  The disappointment set in.  

Two men named Abel Armitage is one too many, in my opinion.  My great-grandmother, Elizabeth, was born to Abel and Eliza (Hartley) Armitage.  Eliza died not long after Elizabeth was born, and a few years later Abel married Ann Bell.  Abel and Ann named their one of their sons Abel B. Armitage.  Usually I see him as Abel Armitage, without the B, which makes it uncertain which Abel I'm reading about.  But clearly, the Abel in this article is not my great-great-grandfather.

I'll just keep searching now and then or when a new collection becomes available.

I love the old newspapers that had gossipy columns about the goings-on of people in the community.  It allows me to put together just a little more about the lives of ancestors.  If only I could find an obituary or even a notice about the last years of my Abel Armitage in one of those newspapers!

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Monday, August 4, 2025

Beverly -- My Babysitter, My Cousin

Our little village of Mineral Ridge was abundant with Bickerstaff relatives.  It seemed wherever there was a group of people, at least one of them was an aunt or uncle or cousin to some degree or other.  Most were my grandmother's siblings, the sons and daughters of Edward Jesse and Mary (Thompson) Bickerstaff and many were their descendants who were also nieces, nephews, and great--nieces and -nephews of my grandmother.  Most were older then me though there were a few who were about my age, and a few more who were about my brother's and sister's ages.

But this post isn't about my cousin Emma, it's about her daughter, Beverly. My parents rarely went out but when they did, either Beverly or another Bickerstaff cousin, Janet, came to stay with me.  Sadly, I don't have any specific memories of Beverly other than that I liked spending time with her. 

I wish this were a better photo.  Beverly is looking down and her eyes are closed.  But one doesn't need to see eyes to know how wonderful she was when you can see the two little children hugging her.  From the photo, you can see how my neighbor Frankie and I adored her.  This photo was probably taken in the summer of 1953.  

Beverly's son, Kirk, contacted me a few years ago and we reconnected last week.  I told him I'd post this photo, though I'm sure he has plenty of better photos of his mom when she was younger. 

I have one other comment about this photo:  look at how curly Beverly's hair was.  Those were natural curls.  I wonder from which side of her family she inherited them. 

I'm thinking about her curls because in recent months my hair has turned curly because of a medication I take.  For many years it was wavy, but never curly (or so I thought).  When I was looking for this photo of Beverly, I came upon a photo of myself when I was about 13 and was shocked.  I've seen this photo before (without really seeing it?) and well, of course I was there when it was taken.  But those curls!   Where did they come from?  Was there a Bickerstaff ancestor who had curls?  Any ideas, Kirk?

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Thursday, July 31, 2025

However Did Our Ancestors Manage in Summer's Heat and Humidity?

(Edited to add:  I neglected to mention that when I talk about heat and humidity, I'm also including the effects of a high dew point which, I think, is the true culprit in how the air feels on our bodies.  A dew point above about 60o, in combination with high humidity, can make the air feel sticky.  The higher the dew point, the more humid it feels.  With a dew point of 76o or above, the air feels miserable, almost like you're trying to swim in the air or walking into a soft, moist, invisible wall.  I'm sure our ancestors were affected by high dew points though they may not have understood the concept at that time.)

During this summer's awful heat and humidity in Central Ohio, I can't help thinking about my ancestors who lived before electricity (think fans and air conditioning), or indoor plumbing (think running water and showers).  How did they manage?  I know most people of earlier times were hardy but even so, it couldn't have been easy.   

I have farmers among my ancestors as well as a gardener, coal miners, carpenters, and other laborers; other families had blacksmiths (oh, the heat with that job!), farriers, builders, etc.  The coal miners who were below ground probably weren't bothered by heat, but the others....  I used to think I would enjoy living in the world and times of some of my ancestors but these days, I lean more toward gratitude that I have so many modern conveniences.  

How did our ancestors cope with severe heat?  I've collected a few ideas from historical books I've read, from visits to historical villages, from common sense, and a few from the websites at the end of this post.

Keeping Homes Cool
-- Windows, especially second story windows, were opened at night if the outside air was cooler than inside.  Downstairs windows were opened in the early morning to let cool air flow into the house and closed before the temperatures rose too high.
-- In the heat of day, windows were closed and blinds/curtains were drawn to keep out the heat.
-- Some homes were built with summer's heat in mind and were located with trees to shade the house; with windows placed to create cross-ventilation.  High ceilings allowed warm air to rise. 
-- Awnings shaded windows from the hot sun.
-- Porches or verandas offered shade in the heat of day.
Summer kitchen at Slate Run Farm
-- Some homes had a summer kitchen, a small building with windows and chimney, a few steps from the house.where food was prepared to keep the heat out of the main house.  That kitchen might have had its own stove or the kitchen stove from the house might have been moved both spring/summer and fall/winter.  Without a summer kitchen, hot food would have been prepared early in the day to eat later.  You can sometimes still see summer kitchens when driving in the country.  If you see a home with an outbuilding (that's not a garage) near the house, it's very possible it was a summer kitchen at one time.  The one at right is spectacular because it has an extended roof where laundry, preparation for canning, and other chores could be done protected from both sun and rain. (But not protected from the heat and humidity!)
-- Some homes had sleeping porches or screened in porches where family members could sleep almost outside.  It's usually cooler at night though possibly not less humid.

Keeping Food Cool
-- If a home was located near a spring, there might have been a spring house, a small building built over the spring.  The spring house usually had shelves where food could be placed to keep it cool (but not cold), and may have had shelves almost at the level of the water.
-- Food might also have been submerged in a spring or a nearby stream to keep it cool.
-- Some communities, and possibly companies, cut ice from lakes in the winter and stored it for use in the summer, especially important after ice boxes were invented.

Keeping the Body Cool
-- Work that didn't have to be done in midday heat was done in the cool of the morning or later in the evening.  People often rested during midday or performed tasks that could be done in the shade or in a lower level of the house or barn where it would have been cooler.
-- People wore cotton and linen clothing that was lighter in both color and thickness during the hot days of summer. 
-- Men and women and some children wore hats to shade their heads and faces.  
-- People might have worked under a shady tree, or rested or cooled off after they'd finished a bout of work.  At right, my father rests on the picnic table after some laborious work around the house.  From the spots on his flat cap it looks as though he may have been painting, possibly interrupted by rain.  Notice the wet driveway.
-- People moved more slowly.
-- They used hand fans.  (In particular I recall our church having hand fans with images of the Savior and quotes from the Bible in the hymnbook holder in each pew. 
-- And certainly people knew the need to drink plenty of water.
-- Children might have enjoyed playing in a stream, creek, or lake.  Adults may have done likewise.  Or they may have taken off their shoes and socks to cool their feet in the water which would have cooled their whole bodies.

My Own Experiences with Summer Heat in the 1950s
I grew up without air conditioning.  In fact, we didn't live in a home with air conditioning until 25 years ago.  What a thrill it was when we first moved here.  We thought it a luxury then.  Now we think it essential.  

When I was very young there was no "city water" in the village where we lived.  My parents bought water by the truckload and had it delivered and poured into a cistern near the house.  It almost seemed as though my mom tracked every drip of water, so there was no outdoor water play---no hose to spray each other, no washtub to sit and splash in, not water balloons.  Just heat and humidity.  Several summers my parents rented a cabin for a week at a nearby lake.  Gosh, that seemed like heaven with the water so near.

I don't think air conditioning had been invented by the 1950s, or if it had, it hadn't reach any of the places we lived or shopped.  Even the large city department stores had huge fans on long poles close to the ceiling that circulated the air.  In our home, we had one or two fans.  Our upstairs consisted of one hallway with four rooms opening off it.  My mom put a fan in the hallway where no one could feel it.  I would have laid in front of it in the hall if my mom would have let me.

On the first floor of our house, the only window that opened (or, at least, the only window I ever saw open) was above the kitchen sink.  This meant that the windows could not be opened at night to let the cool air in.  There was not much ventilation on the first floor.  But but it helped a little to turn on the fan. 

Mom closed the curtains downstairs during the heat of day.  She believed that would keep the afternoon heat out and help the house feel cooler.  It might have worked if it was just heat, but we also contended with high humidity and dew points.  On the days she closed the whole house, it seemed stifling, confining, and sweltering to me! 

We did have a great front porch.  It faced south and was shaded by a large maple tree.  We kids spent a lot of time on that porch playing cards or other games.  And it was a great place to watch the storms and rain and feel the cooling breezes.  

The last cooling method I can remember is ice cream and popsicles.  I could walk a quarter of a block to Main Street, turn left, walk a block, cross a side street, and find myself at Isaly's.  It was an ice cream and sandwich shop.  A single dip of ice cream in a waffle cone was a nickle, a double dip in a cake cone was a dime, and I can't remember the cost of a skyscraper cone.  Popsicles were a nickle, too.  Those treats were not daily occurrences (our mother was careful about sweets and our teeth) but they were welcome when she did give us permission to go to Isaly's.  (If you go to the Isaly's website linked above, our store looked very much like the Pittsburgh-branch store in the cluster of six photos.)

Do you have stories of ancestors and how they stayed cool in the summer?  How did you and your family stay cool if you didn't have air conditioning?  I wish I had family stories of my own.  I can imagine my Aunt Dot (Doris Meinzen Dray, born in 1921) saying, "We just lived with it."  

Resources
11 Ways People Beat the Heat Before Air Conditioning by Elizabeth Yuko
https://www.history.com/articles/11-ways-people-beat-the-heat-before-air-conditioning

“The heat is beyond your conception:”  Staying Cool in 18th-Century Virginia
https://livesandlegaciesblog.org/2017/08/31/the-heat-is-beyond-your-conception-staying-cool-in-18th-century-virginia/

Spending Time in an 18th Century Summer 
https://passionforthepast.blogspot.com/2020/06/spending-time-in-18th-century-summer.html

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Friday, July 25, 2025

SNGF on July 19 Took Me Down a Rabbit Hole Searching for Abel Armitage

Randy Seaver offered a fun activity (fun and easy, depending on the ancestor) for last week's Saturday Night Genealogy Fun (SNGF) on July 19.  
  1. FamilySearch Full-Text Search continues to add databases and searchable images to their collections.  This is a gold mine, especially of land, probate and court records.
  2. Pick one or two of your ancestors and see what you can find on FamilySearch Full-Text Search about them.
Yes, Fun! I thought.  I'll look for my second-great-grandfather Abel Armitage (who disappears after about 1881).  This is a search I periodically repeat but had not yet searched on FS's Full-Text Search.  Surely something will turn up this time!

I already knew Abel's birth (1821) and marriage (1847) information; the names of his daughters by his first wife; his approximate immigration date (1864); and where he lived after he arrived (Steubenville, Jefferson, Ohio).  And I knew he was a coal miner in both England and the U.S.  Abel and family are in the 1870 and 1880 U.S. Census with the latter indicating that he'd been unemployed for 8 months and was disabled.  

I also knew that Abel and his wife Ann had sued the city of Steubenville.  Details that I already know from City Council records can be found here, in a previous post. 

The three major facts I'd like to learn about Abel are 
  1.  when he died
  2.  where he died, and
  3.  where he was buried.
And then I'll want to know how he died, who paid for his burial, etc., etc., etc.

I suspected this fun activity could lead me down a rabbit hole again, but no matter, I went to Full-Text Search anyway.  My find this time was this, below (from Steubenville City Council Proceedings, Miscellaneous Records January 1876-March 1882, both image and volume page 403.  Image and volume page 400 give the date as May 10, 1881) which can be viewed here.
Be it ordained by the counsel of the City of Steubenville that there be and hereby is appropriate[d] out of the monies in the Treasury not otherwise appropriate[d] the following Sums of money to the following named here after named namely...
             Abel Armitage   [$] 207.84
I conclude from this that Abel was likely still alive in May, 1881, though it's possible he had already died.

But why I can't I find him?  My thoughts about what might have happened to Abel after 1881 and why I can't find evidence of ran along these lines:
  • Did he die in a coal mine accident?  If so, in Ohio?  Or in West Virginia?  Or in Pennsylvania?  Those three states "meet" along the Ohio River.  As a coal miner, he could have moved to any of them.  I know both Pennsylvania and West Virginia had coal mines.  But he might not have died in a coal mine accident. 
  • After collecting $207.84 from the Steubenville City Council, might he have moved back to England?  Of course that took me to websites to check on the cost of travel from Ohio to England, via train, then ship, between 1881 and 1910.  He would have had enough money, unless he owed more than half of it to the lawyer.  I did a brief search to see if there was an Abel Armitage living in Durham or West Yorkshire, England, after 1881.  I didn't see him yet.
  • What about the pronunciation of his name?  Would it sound like it's written?  Ar-ma-tage?  Or might a British speaker silence the "r" and pronounce it Amitage,, or Amidage, or even Ammatage?  So I had to see if I could learn how the British might pronounce it.  Turns out it is pronounced in a variety of ways, including with a nearly silent "r."  Pronunciation could affect how the name is spelled in U.S. English, which means I need to search for a variety of spellings in records.
  • And then there are spelling/misspelling variations in records, such as Harmitage, Amitadge, Armetage, Armittage, etc.  I had to look up those variations, too.

While this rabbit hole didn't take me to more records for Abel Armitage, I have ideas of places to continue my search now.
  1. I should find out the location of mines near the Ohio River in all three states.
  2. I should look for a death record and probate and property records in Pennsylvania and West Virginia, specifically the counties that had coal mines.
  3. I should do a more in-depth search of records in England, especially in the counties where I knew he lived.  Abel Armitage is not a common name, but it's more common in England than one would think.
  4. My searches need to be broader in the spelling of the last name, in the time range, and in possible locations. 
Where, oh where could Abel have gone, and where could he have died, and is there a record to find?

Thank you, Randy, for a week's worth of genealogy fun going down a rabbit hole.  It's good to think more thoroughly about possibilities for ancestors.  My searches this week didn't lead to Abel's end, but I'm not giving up yet!

Do you have ancestors from the 1800s that you're unable to find?

If any of you readers have suggestions for me, I'd be thrilled to read them.  Thank you.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Tuesday, July 22, 2025

Finding Red House Farm in Steubenville Township, Jefferson County, Ohio + What You May Find on a Historic County Map

Being curious about the location of the property Robert Nelson sold the coal under in 1869 and first purchased in 1858, I contacted the Genealogy Department of the Public Library of Steubenville and Jefferson County, Ohio, to ask for help.  Specifically I wanted to know about the location of the Red House Farm tract and whether it is currently a subdivision in Jefferson County.  I also mentioned Robert Nelson had purchased property on the tract in 1859.

The helpful librarian found references in several sources, including a map.   Below is a section of the Steubenville map from Atlas of Jefferson Co Ohio by F. W. Beers, 1871.  You can find this map and the full map below at FamilySearch.

You can see Red House Farm on the map and, in the upper left below the horizontal line, you can see R. Nelson.  It really is an R, not an H as it appears at first glance.  Robert originally purchased his property from Matthew Nicholson in 1858, and he was till the owner of much of the land on the Red House Farm tract in 1871.

Red House Farm is really a tract of land, though at one time there may have been a farm with a red house on it on the property.  Below are a few things I learned about Red House Farm.   
  • "The [coperas] works were on top of the hill, at the Red House farm, back of the town."  The coperas works were established by Bazaleel Wells in about 1820.  (Historical Collections of Ohio, In Two Volumes, by Henry Howe, 1900; Volume I, p. 973)
  • Using FamilySearch's Full-Text Search, I found another reference to Red House Farm.  The following is from a deed dated January 12th 1830.  A "...parcel of land heretofore known as part of the Red house farm, formerly the property of Alexander Wells [son of Bazaleel Wells, founder of Steubenville, Ohio], lying immediately below the Town of Steubenville.... containing [more than] 44 acres."  Boundaries are given in metes and bounds which agree with "the survey heretofore to wit on the thirtiest day of July A.D. 1814...."
  • There are more deeds at FamilySearch which mention Red House Farm but this was the earliest. 

Below is the full map of Steubenville and Jefferson County.  For best viewing click on the map so it will open in a new window where you can again enlarge it to look closely.  Or visit FamilySearch where you can also enlarge it
Most of my mother's side of the family comes from Jefferson County, Ohio, so maps like these are a bounty for searching and possibly finding some of my other ancestors and where they lived.

But I was really taken with the lists on the side of this map.  They are almost like a miniature city directory.  These are some of the ways I might use these lists.
  • If I had an ancestor who needed an attorney, would one on this list on this map be one he would have consulted, or would he have gone out of town?
  • The list of companies suggest possible places for employment opportunities.  One of my ancestors was a carpenter.  He may have worked for one of the companies on this list.
  • If I find a marriage record that names the minister but not the church, I might find the minister's name and, thereby, the church where they were married.  Could they and their families have also attended this church?  If so, it's another possible source for more information.
  • If I had a photograph with the photographer's name at the bottom, I might find him on a list like this. 

In general, I think it's interesting to see these brief directories to get a lay of the land where my ancestors lived.  What might they have needed to purchase to live?  What shops were available?  What industries, small businesses, and social opportunities were available at the time?  How many doctors were in town?  With a good map and addresses, I could see how far they would have had to travel to buy bricks or a piece of furniture, fabric or paper, or ready-made clothes.

These kinds of maps interest me for the family history aspect of genealogy.  It's possible that not many county maps have lists like these but it's always worth checking.

In your searches of maps, have you found old ones with information like this one?  Was it helpful or of interest to you?

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Saturday, July 19, 2025

1858 Deed of Purchase - Robert Nelson from Matthew Nicholson

When I find that an ancestor has sold property (or the coal under the property, as Robert Nelson did) I want to learn when he bought the property.  FamilySearch's Full Text Search made it easy.  You can view the record here if you have a free FamilySearch account.

Robert Nelson purchased about four acres of property on the Red House Tract in Steubenville Township, Jefferson County, Ohio, in 1858 from Matthew Nicholson and his wife Hellena.  The boundaries of the property are identified in metes and bounds.  

Transcription:
Matthew Nicholson To Robert Nelson 
Know all men by these presents, that we Matthew Nicholson and Hellena wife of said Mat-
thew Nicholson of the County of Jefferson & State of Ohio, in consideration of the sum of Two 
hundred and six dollars and twenty five cents, in hand paid by Robert Nelson of the same 
place, have bargained and sold, and do hereby grant, bargain, sell and convey, unto the 
said Robert Nelson, his heirs and assigns, forever, a certain tract or parcel of land, being 
a part of the Red house farm, with the appurtenances, situate, lying and being in 
the Township of Steubenville County of Jefferson Ohio, in range No one (1) Township No
Two (2) and Section No Thirty four (34) and described as follows, to wit, beginning at a 
stake in Odberts run where a beech tree 10 in Diam, bears S. 63 ½o  E. 8½ links, the same being 
the N. W. corner of said Nicholson tract of land, running thence S. 8½o  E. 19 perches 
to a rock in the run, thence N. 75¼o  E. 40 perches to a stone top of the hill, thence N. 31o  
W. 5 7/10 perches to a hickory tree, thence N. 17o  W. 10 4/10 perches to a small White oak in Mecnes [? illegible] 
and Scotts South line, thence S. 79 4/10o  W. 36 3/10  perches to the beginning, containing four 
acres & one eighth be the same more or less.  To have & to hold said premises, with the 
appurtenances unto the said Robert Nelson his heirs and assigns forever. And the 
said Matthew Nichelson for himself & heirs doth hereby covenant with said Robert 
Nelson his heirs & assigns, that he is lawfully seized of the premises aforesaid, that they 
are free & clear from all incumbrances, and that he will forever warrant & defend the 
same against all lawful claims whatsoever.  In testimony whereof the said Matthew 
Nickelson & Hellena his wife have hereunto set their hands & seals this " day of May A. D. 1887
Executed in the presence of 
James Melvin              }
Alexander McFarland }
[to the right]  Mathew Nickelson   (seal)
[to the right}  Hellena her X mark Nichelson  (seal)
       The State of Ohio Jefferson County ss
Before the subscriber a Justice of the peace within and for said County personally
[page 323]
appeared Matthew Nicholson and Hellena his wife, the above named parties of the first 
part and acknowledged the signing & sealing of the above conveyance to be voluntary act & 
deed, and the said Hellena wife of the said Matthew Nichelson being at the same time esc- [ex-]
amined by me separate and apart from her said husband, and the contents of said instru-
ment made known to her by me, she then declared that she did voluntarily sign seal and [????]
acknowledge the same, and that she is still satisfied therewith.   Witness my hand this 2nd day of May A.D. 1857.
[to far right]  James Melvin (seal)  Justice of the peace
State of Ohio Jefferson County ss  Recorded September 18th 1858.   George Beatty Recorder

Citation Information:
Deed Record:  Jefferson.  Volume G2, Deeds 1857-1859, Recorders Office, Jefferson County Courthouse
FHL Film 004021964, Item 2, Image 166, volume pages 322-323.  Viewed, saved 3 Jun 2025
Direct link:  https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-892H-K1J4?view=fullText&keywords=Robert%20Nelson%2CNelson%2CRobert%2CJefferson%2COhio%2Cor&lang=en&groupId=]

Notes and Comments
  • Robert Nelson's wife was not named as one of the purchasers of this property.
  • In both this deed and the 1859 deed of sale for the coal under this property, the wives of the men selling the property were included in the ownership and were taken aside and asked independently if they understood what was happening and if they agreed to it.  Might they have been pressured to agree, or was property generally in the realm of the male in 1858?
  • Was there a house already built on this property, or was it already a coal mine, or was it uninhabited woodland? 
  • Robert Nelson owned this property until at least 1859, when he sold the coal under it.  When he purchased it, did he realize there was coal in the ground?  Did he mine part of the coal before he sold the rest in 1859?  (I'll probably never know the answers to these questions but I do wonder.) 
  • Four and 1/8 acres for $206.25 makes the cost about $50.00 per acre.  Today's value of $50.00 is nearly $2,000.00.
  • I find it interesting that there are two dates on this deed.  The first is near the middle with a date of  May, 1887, and the last is at the end with a date of September 18th 1858.  I don't yet know why.

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.

Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Population Through the Decades at Population.us

Edited to add:  I found this site by searching for a city and state + population on Google and it was one of the results.  When I went back to search I found the website difficult to use.  For any who just want to quickly find information on a city and state, this is the url to use:  https://population.us/oh/steubenville/.  Edit it to put in the state and town you are searching for.

This morning I was wondering why so few Steubenville newspapers have been made available and searchable online by companies like OldNews, Newspapers.com, NewspaperArchive, Google Newspaper Archive, Chronicling America, and some of the larger genealogy companies with online newspaper content.  Not a tiny town, Steubenville's across the Ohio River from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  And with at least eight newspapers in publication simultaneously for several decades, Steubenville must have been a fairly large city, right?  

Wrong.  

Population.us tells me that in 1870 Steubenville, Ohio, had 8,107 residents; whereas, Pittsburgh had a population of 86,076 residents, more than ten times larger.  No wonder Steubenville's not high on the list for companies making their newspapers available online.  (It's true they are available at Ohio History Connect, formerly the Ohio Historical Society, but without a date, I might have to read newspapers all day because they are on microfilm and not searchable.)

But this post isn't about Steubenville's population.  It's about a great website for finding the population of an American city through the decades.  I like Population.us for its simplicity and clarity, and because it tells the sources of its information.  

Its brief introduction tells us its website is
about current and historical population statistics for USA country, states, counties and cities (approximately 20000 settlements). Most of the data are from US censuses, some of them since 1790. All information on this website (population statistics, images, population maps etc.) is free for any use (...attribution appreciated)....  

These are the results of my search for Steubenville, Ohio.

This information appears at the top of the screen and gives me brief information about Steubenville's location and population. (Click the image to enlarge in a new tab.)

This graph is clickable on each decade and it tells me the population.


This shows Steubenville on a section of a U.S. map, shows the annual growth rate, and gave me the opportunity to click through to a satellite map.

There is a clickable list of nearby cities and their distance and direction from Steubenville proper.

And these are the source notes at the bottom of the results page.

I've shown sections of the screens because, yes, there are ads to ignore (or use, if you choose).  It's not an ad-free site but I was able to overlook those for the information Population.us offers.

The little village where I grew up is not included in their results and if your ancestors came from a small town, it may not be included, either.  But I think most large and medium cities are.

I think knowing the population of an area where my ancestors lived will help me put into perspective things like possible distance between neighbors, especially in rural areas; availability of purchasing or selling necessities; etc. Add a map, as detailed and possible, and a city directory, and I might be able to imagine living in the community.  I think I'm more of a family historian than a genealogist.  These kinds of things interest me.

If you try Population.us, I'd love to hear what you think.  Perhaps you've already found another site that tells historic population that you use?  Please share.  Maybe it's better than Population.us

—Nancy.

Copyright © 2025 Nancy Messier.  All Rights Reserved. 
Do not copy or use any content from this blog without written permission from the owner. 

.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...